New York City’s food scene is legendary, and when it comes to burgers, the competition is fierce. From hole-in-the-wall establishments to high-end eateries, the Big Apple offers burgers for every craving. In this article, we explore the best burger joints in NYC, spotlighting local favorites, trendy new spots, and timeless classics. Prepare to have your taste buds tantalized as we dive into the city’s juiciest creations.
1. Shake Shack – Madison Square Park
The Iconic Favorite
Few burger joints have achieved global fame the way Shake Shack has. What started as a humble food kiosk in Madison Square Park has exploded into an international sensation. Known for its fluffy potato buns, well-seasoned patties, and signature ShackSauce, it still holds a nostalgic charm for locals. The ShackBurger remains a top pick for anyone craving a perfectly balanced burger experience.
Recommended Order: ShackBurger with Crinkle-Cut Fries and a Black & White Shake.
2. J.G. Melon – Upper East Side
Classic American Nostalgia
Since 1972, J.G. Melon has been a go-to spot for simple, no-frills burgers. Stepping inside feels like entering an old-school tavern, where the focus is on quality ingredients and consistent flavors. Their thick, juicy patty served on a toasted bun with just lettuce, tomato, and pickles is pure burger bliss.
Pro Tip: Get a side of their cottage fries—chunky, crisped potato coins that are impossible to resist.
3. Au Cheval – Tribeca
Gourmet Burger Bliss
Originally from Chicago, Au Cheval opened its NYC outpost to rave reviews, bringing a touch of luxury to the burger world. Known for its rich, buttery brioche bun and double-stacked patties, this joint elevates the burger game. The perfectly fried egg and thick-cut bacon add extra decadence. Prepare to wait, though—this spot is always packed.
Recommended Order: Double Cheeseburger with a fried egg and bacon.
4. Minetta Tavern – Greenwich Village
Old World Charm Meets Modern Burger Excellence
Minetta Tavern’s “Black Label Burger” is something of a legend. This premium burger uses a dry-aged blend of beef that gives it a deep, rich flavor, unlike anything you’d expect from a traditional patty. With caramelized onions and a light brioche bun, it’s as elegant as a burger can get—and priced accordingly.
Recommended Order: The Black Label Burger with a glass of Pinot Noir.
5. Superiority Burger – East Village
The Veggie Revolution
Not every great burger needs meat. Superiority Burger is beloved by vegetarians and carnivores alike for its signature plant-based burger that’s crispy on the outside and tender inside. The East Village joint offers a rotating selection of veggie-forward options and quirky sides that cater to a health-conscious but flavor-hungry crowd.
Must-Try Dish: The Superiority Burger paired with burnt broccoli salad.
6. Emily – West Village
The Pizza Joint with a Burger That Stole the Show
Though better known for its pizza, Emily’s “Emmy Burger” is one of the most talked-about burgers in NYC. Made with a dry-aged beef patty, caramelized onions, American cheese, and a pretzel bun slathered with secret sauce, it delivers an irresistible sweet-savory punch. It’s a messy, glorious experience that lives up to the hype.
Recommended Order: Emmy Burger with the curly fries.
7. Corner Bistro – West Village
A Dive Bar Classic
Corner Bistro has been serving up its no-nonsense, budget-friendly burgers since the 1960s. This beloved dive bar keeps it simple: a thick beef patty, melted cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato—all for under $12. Locals love it for its unpretentious vibe and late-night hours, making it a go-to after-hours spot.
Pro Tip: Pair the Bistro Burger with a cold beer for the full experience.
Verdict: Where to Start?
Whether you prefer fast-casual options or gourmet creations, NYC offers a burger joint for everyone. For a quick, crowd-pleasing fix, Shake Shack never disappoints. If you’re seeking indulgence, Au Cheval or Minetta Tavern will deliver on every level. For vegetarians or the health-conscious, Superiority Burger is the top choice. No matter where you go, these burgers prove that in New York, good food is always within reach.
So, grab your appetite and head to one of these burger havens—because in a city that never sleeps, the burgers never stop sizzling.
Hungry for More? Keep your eyes peeled—new burger joints are always popping up in NYC. Stay tuned for seasonal menu updates and limited-time specials!
